2-15-2013 New York:
County Executive Steve Bellone has signed a bill passed last week that ends "clustered" housing of registered sex offenders, putting an end to the two trailers used to shelter the county's homeless sex offenders. The legislature's minority leader still questions why the new law had to be pushed through so quickly and wonders aloud whether the $900,000 annual contract granted to a private contractor should have been subject to a competitive proposal process.
Though hailed by Suffolk Police Chief James Burke as "the most comprehensive law in the nation" for dealing with registered sex offenders — as well as by East End legislators delighted that the seven-year saga of the county trailers in Riverside and Westhampton will finally come to an end — both the law and the process by which it was enacted have drawn sharp criticism.
Civil rights advocates question the constitutionality of vesting a private entity with quasi-law enforcement authority to undertake intensive home surveillance of registered offenders. Others, including the legislative minority leader, Republican Jack Kennedy of Nesconset, are troubled by the hasty adoption of the law and the $900,000-a-year contract it awards to a the Stony Brook-based Parents for Megan's Law group, without first soliciting competitive proposals.
The county executive pushed the bill through the legislature in a single day, submitting it to lawmakers on the morning of their Feb. 5 general meeting. It was called for a public hearing and submitted to a vote that very afternoon.
That flies in the face of democracy and sound public policy, according to the director of the Suffolk chapter of the N.Y. Civil Liberties Union.
"The bill was introduced, updated, subject to a public hearing and voted on within three or four hours," NYCLU Suffolk director Amol Sindha said in an interview this week.
Bellone's office issued a certificate of necessity, which allows the legislature to forgo its normal committee process in deliberating a bill. The CN, as it is known, is "a time-sensitive request" by the county executive on a resolution that requires "immediate consideration," according to the county's website.
But use of a CN is a sensitive subject around the horseshoe in the legislative auditorium — and one that doesn't sit well at all with Kennedy. At last week's meeting, Kennedy questioned the need to circumvent the committee process. He was joined in his reservations by members of the Republican caucus. In the end, they all voted to approve the measure.
This week found the minority leader second-guessing himself in that decision.
"There is much ambiguity in the administrative code and the county charter," Kennedy said in a phone interview Wednesday. "We have, in essence, empowered the county executive to utilize this. But it clearly is supposed to be for a situation that's emergent," Kennedy said.
This was not such a situation, but instead was one of political expediency, he said.
Then why vote to approve? Lawmakers passed the measure unanimously — by a voice vote.
Kennedy said both Bellone and Parents for Megan's Law executive director Laura Ahearn lobbied hard to get legislators on board with the bill and approval by CN. Kennedy said he knew most, if not all, other legislators would support Bellone's effort on this hot-button issue.
"There was a sense of inevitability," Kennedy said.
And he did not want to stand alone in opposition to a bill that would be embraced by the public as a "get tough" law on sex offenders. Such opposition comes with a price tag, as he learned the hard way, he said. Kennedy cast the lone no vote on the county's residency restrictions law for registered sex offenders. It was a hugely unpopular vote and he lost the support of his party because of it. He found himself in a tough primary battle to win nomination for re-election.
"It was no fun," said Kennedy, who reiterated his belief that the residency law is unconstitutional. That issue is currently before a court and officials acknowledged last week the county is likely to lose the case — as has every other municipality that's enacted restrictions on where registered sex offenders can live.
"We put this feel-good pablum out there for the public, making them think they'll be safer," Kennedy said. "And now we've spent a tremendous amount of taxpayer money to defend bad legislation." The Republican leader said he's concerned the county is going down the same path with the new law, dubbed the "Community Protection Act."
Of particular concern, Kennedy said, is that the law empowers a private organization with responsibility for verifying the home addresses of the county's registered sex offenders.
Equally troubling, Kennedy said, is the approval of a $2.7 million, three-year contract with a private entity without details of the contractor's responsibilities being disclosed to lawmakers and without submitting the contract to any sort of competitive process, Kennedy said.
"Bellone will say they're a sole source provider and bring it before the waiver committee," Kennedy said. That will allow the administration to circumvent the county's procurement policy that otherwise requires the county to issue a request for proposals for all contracts in excess of $25,000, he said. "That's the only way they could thread the needle."
"I wouldn't deem Parents for Megan's Law the only entity in Suffolk County to do what the contract requires," Kennedy said. "And we don't even know what that is. There's nothing defined yet," he said. "But there are other victim services agencies in this county."
"By local law and after public debate, the county has satisfied the procurement guidelines under state and local law for this type of contract," Vanessa Baird-Streeter, a spokesperson for Bellone said in an email yesterday.
The public had an opportunity to comment on the measure at both a presentation given to the legislature's public safety committee on Thursday, Jan. 31 and at the general meeting the following Tuesday, Feb. 5.
But the bill itself was not available to the public until the afternoon of the Feb. 5 hearing. It was not posted on the legislature's website until after it was adopted.
"To call it a public hearing is essentially a farce," NYCLU's Sinha said.
Others, like Kennedy, are troubled by the bill's lack of specifics about the duties of Parents for Megan's Law under the $900,000 annual contract.
Forensic psychologist Bill O'Leary, who, under contract with the state, works with registered sex offenders, points out that 95 percent of sex crimes against children are committed by people who are not on any registry.
"If we really want to protect our children from sexual predators, we need to address that instead of focusing all our resources on the registered offenders who re-offend, which represents a statistically small portion of those crimes," O'Leary said in an interview.
O'Leary made the same argument to lawmakers at the hearing last week, pleading with the legislature dedicate resources to prevention through education, and by strengthening its child protective services unit, which has suffered budget cuts.
"If there's money to be spent, that's where the county should spend it," O'Leary said at the hearing. He got no response from lawmakers at the meeting.
The new law, in the section authorizing the contract with Parents for Megan's Law, lists six types of services the organization will provide. Item six reads: "the provision of community and prevention education."
Kennedy, who complained at last week's meeting that the bill did not have the proposed contract attached to it, which he said was the norm, reiterated that complaint in an interview with RiverheadLOCAL this week.
"When you look at the research, it's frightening — the small number of sex crimes committed by registered offenders, as opposed to people not on any registry. Yet we're still so focused on the registry," Kennedy said.
"It's missing the forest for the trees."
Riverhead Assessor Mason Haas, who spoke on behalf of the town in support of the bill at the hearing, agreed more emphasis should be placed on prevention and education.
"There's no doubt it needs to be tweaked," Haas said. But as a longtime advocate for closing down the homeless-offender trailers, Haas said the new program represents the local community's best shot at making that happen.
During a break in the public portion of last week's meeting, Haas engaged in a discussion with O'Leary about education and prevention initiatives needed and Parents for Megan's Law might do in that regard under the new contract.
Haas suggested the two speak with Ahearn, who was also in the lobby of the Hauppauge auditorium. Ahearn refused to discuss it in the presence of O'Leary, Haas said.
O'Leary said he was not surprised. He said Ahearn has refused to talk with him, or respond to his calls or emails for some time.
Ahearn acknowledged her refusal in an interview this week.
"It's my understanding he has a practice in which he provides services to sex offenders," Ahearn said. In her opinion, she said, he has no place in a county program monitoring sex offenders, counseling victims or crafting education and prevention programs.
"I'm sure if he [O'Leary] wants to expand his efforts he has the wherewithal to go out and find grant funding to do it," Ahearn said.
"If you saw the presentation, if you took the additional time to listen, you know the program includes significant victims services and prevention initiatives," Ahearn said.
Parents for Megan's Law would be hiring "additional prevention staff" to undertake those services, she said.
In a presentation to the county legislature's public safety committee on Jan. 31, Ahearn outlined a "sex offender tracking and community support eight-point plan." Under the new program, the organization would establish a 24-hour hotline providing access to a trained specialist, she said. An education supervisor will "conduct extensive outreach to schools and community organizations and train per-diem prevention educators to conduct sexual abuse, abduction and rape prevention workshops and Internet safety programs. The group will also enhance its existing crime victim advocacy support programs, she said.
The slide presentation given by Ahearn and the Suffolk police chief can be viewed here.
O'Leary said he does not understand how an effective program to prevent sexual crimes could be undertaken without consulting any mental health experts on the criminals themselves. He said he has expressed that sentiment to the county executive and was hoping for a meeting with him.
The county's process in crafting and adopting the new law was "not informed decision-making," O'Leary said. "It's not defining the real problem and putting the solution ahead of defining the problem."
O'Leary said the general public is terrified of registered offenders. "As the father of two young children, I completely relate," he said. "But that fear is largely misplaced. The real threat comes from trusted relatives and family friends. People you know. They are the people who are far more likely to molest your child. It's a difficult thing to come to terms with. But if we really want to prevent abuse, we need to teach parents and children where the real threat lies and teach them how to recognize warning signs. We don't need to use scare tactics and we certainly shouldn't lead people to believe the main threat is from people on a registry.
Advocates for reforming registry laws argue that's exactly what the registry laws and groups like Parents for Megan's Law do.
An organization called USAFair, established in 2012 by family members of registered sex offenders to advocate for the reform of registry laws, faults lawmakers, the media and groups like Parents for Megan's Law for what they say is exaggerating the likelihood of a registered offender re-offending.
"A 2010 survey by the Center for Sex Offender Management of the U.S. Department of Justice found that 72 percent of Americans believe that the sex crime recidivism rates are 50 percent or higher, with a third believing it is more than 75 percent. Only 3 percent believe it is less than 25 percent - even though actual recidivism rates are considerably below 25 percent," USAFair said in a Feb. 4 press release. "New studies are constantly confirming low recidivism, with the latest being released last month showing a recidivism rate in four states of 10 percent after 10 years, with rates dropping sharply with years of offense-free tenure in the community. https://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/nij/grants/240099.pdf
USAFair faults Ahearn's group in particular, arguing that the Parents for Megan's Law website misrepresents recidivism statistics.
"USA FAIR has been attempting to get Parents for Megan's Law to take down misleading statistics from their website that reinforces the 'big lie' of high sex offender recidivism," the organization said in a statement. "Numerous studies, including a landmark 2003 study by the U.S. Justice Department have found that sex offenders actually have one of the lowest recidivism rates in the criminal justice system, about 5.3 percent."
Shana Rowan, a USAFair founder, said she wrote to Ahearn in December seeking changes to statistics on the PFML website that she says misrepresent the results of a study on repeat offenders. Ahearn never replied to the letter.
"As executive director of Parents for Megan's Law, Laura Ahearn has shown herself to be a zealot who has built a career demonizing the very people she is now to be charged with monitoring. She has perpetuated the myth of high sex offender recidivism, despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary, to enrich her organization," Rowan said.
Ahearn dismissed Rowan's criticism, pointing to Rowan's engagement to a registered offender who she said "raped a six year old child." Ahearn also said Rowan is "part of NAMBLA," the North American Man/Boy Love Association.
Rowan categorically denies that she has ever in any way been associated with NAMBLA. A website called evil-unveiled.com has a page with her name in the URL, and it's the top hit in a Google search of her name. The page says she is a member of "the new NAMBLA" a name the website gives to "activists" seeking reform of registry laws so that they can have sex with children.
"I think it's very telling that she would resort to personal attacks instead of discussing the issues on the merits," Rowan said this week.
Rowan said as the recipient of signifcant public funding — Parents for Megan's Law's 2011 federal tax return reports the group received more than $946,000 in government grants in 2011, the lion's share of its total revenue of just under $1.1 million — the group should be held accountable for providing accurat information to the public. "That was really all we were seeking," Rowan said. "The new deal with Suffolk County is a whole other subject," she said.
"Parents for Megan's Law has no experience in sex offender management - none," Rowan said, questioning how the county could "sole-source such an important and costly contract without even considering truly qualified parties - such as the Association for the Treatment of Sexual Abusers, who are mental health professionals and sex-offender policy researchers. Rowan said the vote by the legislature was "a political attempt to purchase Laura Ahearn's support for the controversial proposal at great cost to the taxpayer."
Asked to respond to the criticism of USAFair, the county executive's spokesperson said, "No comment." ..Source.. by Denise Civiletti
February 15, 2013
New sex offender bill signed, but questions persist
May 18, 2010
Sex Offenders Found Living in Clusters in SoCal, Find Out Where
Notice how the media referrs to registrants as "sex offenders" and "Sex Criminals" hyping the hysteria about registrants. A goodly portion of registrants were convicted YEARS-AGO and should not be called names for the sake of sensationalizing the story of how the punitive laws force them to live in unsafe run down areas of the city, affecting registrants families as well, none of which deserve what authorities are doing to them and their futures..5-18-2010 California:
LOS ANGELES -- A KTLA analysis of the Megan's Law database finds clusters of sex offenders living in some Southern California neighborhoods, while others have virtually none.
When we conducted our research last month, we found one zip code in Wilmington -- 90744 -- with more registered sex offenders living in it than any other in the region.
One block of Flint Avenue in Wilmington was home to 94 registered sex offenders.
Most have done time for victimizing kids. They live in run-down apartments. Thirty of them in this one building, The Harbor Inn, where the manager, who told us his name was Joseph, makes no apologies.
"They have to have somewhere to stay," he told us. "They are human beings."
Flint Avenue is an industrial area near the port and a refinery. It's not close to homes, schools, or parks.
Still, if you took a wrong turn and ended up here, there's no sign to warn you this is a neighborhood full of sexual predators.
What we found here is typical.
Our research on the Megan's Law database found that the 90744 zip code Wilmington has the most, with 202, followed by a zip code in Lancaster with 157, 137 in a part of Long Beach.... and 118 in a section of Compton.
Sex criminals tend to live in poorer parts of town.
You'll find none in zip codes in Encino, San Marino, Pacific Palisades, and Newport Beach... and only one in Beverly Hills.
Orange County Assistant District Attorney Todd Spitzer says sex offenders are generally unemployable, and tend to live on public assistance. He says they can only afford cheap housing.
The law says they're not supposed to live within 2,000 feet of a school.
But we found plenty that do.
In Maywood, just across the street from Loma Vista Elementary, there's a duplex that's home to a convicted child molester.
He wasn't around when we knocked.
Some prosecutors think California needs to get tougher on sex offenders by keeping them in prison longer, monitoring them with GPS for life, or forcing them to live farther away from people.
Assistant District Attorney Spitzer thinks confining sex offenders to the high desert might be a good plan.
"I don't think it's a laughable idea," he told KTLA.
But back on Flint Ave. in Wilmington, there's a different attitude.
Joseph, the manager of an apartment building that houses 30 sex offenders, told KTLA, "People have to open their hearts and forgive." ..Source.. KTLA-TV
August 16, 2009
AL- Motel garners cluster of sex offenders
8-16-2009 Alabama:
____ sees himself in his motel's clientele.
As an answer to the whisper campaign and public contempt hurled at his business, the manager posted an atypical sign out front.
"Sexual predators may rent a room from time to time. The law does not require them to notify management to rent a room at any hotel anywhere and we may be unaware of their presents (sic). This is an adult community only."
That is what greets guests at Shady Court Motel on East 12th Avenue in Sheffield. It's a series of older, white standalone units separated by sparse grass, just off Sheffield's main drag.
For years, it has been a vacuum for released sex offenders, as it is the listed address for nearly a dozen, according to the Alabama Department of Public Safety.
Colbert County authorities say 12 sex offenders live there now.
The motel's manager knew of seven.
Included in the motel's community are some arrested for sexually abusing children, raping teenagers and sodomy, according to the sex offender list.
"It's real hard for them to find a place to live," said ___, who at first refused to give his name because of the stigma associated with sex offenders. "It puts a big target on their back. They have to live somewhere, though."
He, too, knows the difficulty of starting over.
He is on the sex offender list - something revealed only after he was asked.
On Friday, ____ delved into the challenges of re-entering society after committing a sexual crime.
"It's made my life a living hell," the motel manager said. "I have worked so hard to get back up. But I can't even go to the grocery store without fear of someone coming up to me. It's on my driver's license. There's a whole lot about (the list) that's just not fair."
____ said he has refused applicants whose crimes he believed were too violent.
"I turn them away if I can," he said. "I like to keep it to no more than five (convicted sex offenders) around here if I can."
There are more there now. And when people ask, he just points to the sign, not mentioning he is one of the "sexual predators" in the community.
He differentiates himself from others, saying he wants more rigid categories to label sex crimes - and restrictions that come with them.
He was arrested in Cullman County in 1991 for first-degree sexual abuse of a 7-year-old girl.
Now, in a way, he's a de facto law officer.
The influx of sex offenders at his motel comes with increased police attention. Colbert County Assistant Chief Deputy Mike Aday said Starnes reports any problems he sees with his residents. Aday said ____' information has led to arrests in the past.
"He's one of them that doesn't give me any problems," Aday said of ___, who is among 100 sex offenders in Colbert County. "We greatly appreciate the help he gives us."
State law requires sex offenders to live at least 2,000 feet away from schools, day care centers or other havens for children. They must also stay 1,000 feet away from their victim.
Offenders also must report to authorities every six months and register when they move or change employment. If offenders move, authorities have to first make sure the new residence meets standards.
It's these rules, Aday said, that funnels so many to Shady Court. He said it's far easier to find housing in rural areas but few choose that route.
"It's a place they know they can get into right away," he said of the motel.
He added that a handful also go to a nearby motel.
Though boarding convicted sex offenders brings public scorn, it's also guaranteed business.
"It's a catch-22," he said. "These are among the most stable people we have here. They pay rent on time, but we don't want to be known as the sex-offender palace."
There isn't much sympathy for Shady Court from neighbors, with the general consensus favoring demolition.
"I hate that place," said Dolores Lansdell, who owns the house closest to the motel. "They should all burn."Kelly Muston, who monitors sex offenders for the Lauderdale County Sheriff's Office, believes stricter restrictions are needed, such as dictating distance between a sex offender's home and a bus stop, which has been included in other states' laws.
"They put themselves in that position when they committed that crime," she said, adding she couldn't say if convicted sex offenders can change their mindset, as ___ claims.
Lauderdale County has 80 sex offenders, she said; there are 45 in Franklin County, according to the sheriff's department there.Clearly Muston knows little about sex offenders -or how the human mind works- even though she sees them regularly. An unwillingness to discuss the crime is not denial, its normal human behavior, crimes like many thing in life are personal. While registries make the criminal record public, nothing forces the offender to talk about it for the rest of their lives. Many folks have done far worse and moved on, sex offenders are not allowed the same.
In context, that makes one sex offender for every 547 people in Colbert, 684 people in Franklin and 1,114 in Lauderdale.
Muston said denial is rampant among those she deals with.
"Some have this attitude of 'I did my time; it's over, let me move on,' " she said. "That doesn't mean it ended for the victim. That's something the victim has to live with for the rest of their life."
Meanwhile, ____ is still trying to run his business, which he admits "isn't exactly a four-star hotel."
He leads sexual addiction meetings in the parking lot and gives his number in case someone needs an intervention.
A couple of people always show at the meetings.
____ said he hasn't been behind bars since his arrest nearly 20 years ago. He said he's proof sex offenders can change.
"It's an ongoing process," he said. "You have to be brutally honest with yourself about what you did. I'm not going to make no excuses for it. It was absolutely horrible. But luckily, I don't have those thoughts anymore."
He's now engaged. His fiance knows about his past, he said. "I'm not a monster out there trying to hurt somebody," Starnes said. "I'm just trying to live and make things right with God and myself. I never want to go back to that person I was." ..Source.. by Brian Hughes, Staff Writer
March 24, 2008
FL- Sex offenders tend to live in clusters
There is a new theory developing one that has no basis in fact, that lawmakers should enact "no loitering" laws instead of residency restrictions. All this theory is, is a compromise with lawmakers. Reality is, there is no proof whatsoever, that, loitering is a factor in sex offenses or contributes to sexual offending. I would like to see a single study which shows "loitering" contributes to sex offenses.
3-23-2008 Florida:
Down a widely known street, where beautiful houses and inexpensive apartments share a canopy of trees between U.S. 1 and the Indian River, lives a registered sex offender.
And another. And another. And another.
The tiny white bungalows, cottages and trailers at 2664 Pineapple Ave., two miles north from Eau Gallie Boulevard, are home to four registered sex offenders and the last known address for a fifth who fled from house arrest.
No other Brevard County address boasts that many registered sex offenders, according to a FLORIDA TODAY analysis of more than 900 offenders identified by the Brevard County Sheriff's Office Web site.
Some addresses show two offenders living in one location, but no single address with such a concentration.
And according to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement Web site, 13 sexual offenders live within one mile of that address, including at least one more on Pineapple Avenue. Bobby Joe Helms, who pleaded guilty and served 13 years in prison in the rapes of a dozen women in the Tampa area, resides on U.S. 1 about a mile and a half north of the Pineapple address.
The fact that so many sex offenders chose the Pineapple Avenue address -- Rocky Water Park Cottages -- is no accident. Property managers Ruth and Jack Sauder consider the complex to be a weigh station for those trying to get back on their feet and those who are maybe on the way down.
"I don't have a problem renting to them," Ruth Sauder said. "They are careful to mind their p's and q's and they give me less trouble than the other tenants."
Florida law requires a 1,000-foot buffer between registered sex offenders and schools, day care centers, parks, churches or libraries. Finding that kind of location -- as well as a willing landlord -- can be tricky.
"There are several residential locations in Brevard County where more than one designated sexual offender or predator may currently live," said sheriff's Cmdr. Doug Waller. "This usually occurs through word of mouth after an offender has found a property owner or manager who will rent or lease and the property location does not conflict with any legislative or ordinance mandate."
Options limited
Child safety advocate Kevin Gillick, who publishes a newspaper devoted to the whereabouts of sexual offenders in the county, says seeing registered offenders living close together may not be a bad thing.
"There are probably some advantages as far as monitoring or tracking offenders," Gillick said. "Concentrating the population has been a traditional way of dealing with a despicable segment of society."
Yes, the Ghetto mentality, which society has used for eons. As long as they are over there then that is OK, because then they are not here -whereever the speaker is-. Society then further denies them based on their ghetto address, a subtle way of further punishing them. eAdvocate
Gillick agreed with Waller that housing options are limited for registered sex offenders.
"When people do background checks and credit checks, then there are not many choices for sex offenders," he said. "It's also likely that they are financially destitute."
Sauder said the only offender she has ever turned away was Helms -- known as the Hyde Park serial rapist from Tampa -- just a few months ago.
"The people here are struggling and trying to make it," she said. "I try to look at the person and not the circumstances."
Helms has been forced to move a couple of times. He finally settled at 3735 N. Harbor City Blvd. Sauder said letting Helms move in would have upset too many people in the complex that has 64 housing units.
Buffer zones vary
While state law already limits housing options for offenders, some municipalities have made it tougher by imposing more restrictions.
In South Florida, for example, many cities and at least two counties have raised the buffer-zone requirements from 1,000 feet to 2,500 feet. This, according to Lynn University Assistant Professor Jill Levenson, has created a transient and homeless population of sex offenders.
A newly proposed state bill would raise the mandatory buffer zones to 1,500 feet statewide and would supercede the 2,500-foot zones.
"Research shows that sex offender restrictions increase transience, homelessness and instability," Levenson said, adding that a population of homeless sex offenders has taken up residence beneath a bridge in Fort Lauderdale.
What Levenson does like about the bill is another facet that would institute "no loitering zones" around schools, playgrounds and bus stops. She recommends keeping the statewide buffer zone at 1,000 feet and starting the "no loitering" zones.
"Right now a sex offender can hang out in a park all day long," Levenson said. "The loitering bill would restrict daytime activities, instead of where someone sleeps at night." ..more.. by Torres at 242-3649 or jtorres@floridatoday.com.
